Search This Blog

Thursday, July 31, 2008

To save a life?

So, I was listening to Bob & the Showgram this morning on the radio. Apparently, there was a survey out there that said that when posed with a situation requiring CPR (a stranger collapses in a mall, for instance), 86% of the population said they would not perform CPR on a stranger.

I found that really interesting. So, I got thinking to myself...I was an EMT for two years and have been trained in CPR several times - would I perform CPR if needed? Nope...probably not. It scares me to think that. If it were a child, that would be a different story. I would do everything I could to save the life of a child, but an adult...nope. Especially if I didn't know you from Jack. My biggest fear would be contracting something..."the herp, the hep, or the hiv" as Bob put it. Scary stuff out there. One act of heroism and I could contract something I could never get rid of.

Now, at work, I have a two-way valve that I keep in my desk drawer just in case, but even if I had that on me, I'm not certain that I would perform mouth-to-mouth - I might borrow it to someone else so that they could. It's a frightening thought to imagine that if I were in a mall and collapsed, only 15% of the people around me might help. And, of that 15%, I bet 10% would freeze and not do it, either. That leaves me one person out of every 20 who might help. Those are not very good odds!

Bob opened the lines for callers...this is what I heard. Two nurses who says they absolutely would not without a two-way valve (and even might not with one), a paramedic who says they absolutely would not and would call 911 instead, and then a gal and a guy who are just "trained in CPR" but have no title who definitely would. But, of all the people in the are who have probably been in that situation, no one called in and said they had. It's interesting that the uninformed are the ones who are willing to do it and those who have been trained refused. One of the nurses also found it necessary to mention that CPR is not always as easy or clean as it looks in the movies. People often vomit, spit blood, and occasionally bite their tongues when they start breathing again. It's a messy process...who wants to be involved in that if they don't have to??? Not me.

Bob also mentioned a study in Tokyo where they checked the effectiveness over mouth-to-mouth w/compressions versus chest compressions alone in saving lives. They found (over a longitudinal study) that chest compressions alone increased the odds of someone surviving a trauma than CPR/compressions did. They made the conclusion that the time spent doing mouth-to-mouth was time taken away from getting the heart beating again and that, especially when EMS was on their way, compressions alone had better results. My thoughts on this: that's probably true for instances like heart trauma and cardiac arrest but what about the instances where someone has a heartbeat but is not breathing? Do you walk away? Call 911? Yell for someone else to please help?

What would you do???

No comments:

Post a Comment