Search This Blog

Saturday, March 14, 2020

Scott's Felony Trial...and all the disappointment that goes with it

So, I FINALLY had court this past week.  After over a year of waiting (my ex was charged with felony malicious punishment of a child under the age of four in Dec 2018).  He's been given every break available to him...claimed sovereign citizenship...continuance after continuance because he's representing himself and doesn't know the rules...etc.  The LAST time we were scheduled to move forward with the trial (January), he claimed that he didn't have time to submit a witness list or any discovery (apparently a YEAR was not long enough).  So, the judge granted another continuance to March.

Before we were allowed to leave, though, he was told that he could question any of the witnesses he wanted as part of discovery, to see what information they'd be offering at trial.  So, he said he wanted to question myself and Emidio.  My son went in first and I wasn't allowed to go into the courtroom with him.  I just sat crying in the hallway.  Emidio came out and seemed okay.  A little sad, but he knocked it out of the park (still remembered the beating and everything).

The bailiff came back out and said they wanted to speak to him again.  So, I sent him back into the courtroom with his abuser a SECOND time.  After a few minutes, the DA and both of the bailiffs came out, but not my son.  I asked what happened and the DA told me that the judge kicked everyone out, he objected, was yelled at and Scott was allowed TIME ALONE in the courtroom with Emidio.  It was off the record and NOBODY else was in the courtroom (aside from, I believe, Scott's standby counsel).

After THAT, I asked Emidio what dad said to him and he said that everything was "okay" now, and it was "okay that Dad spanked me." I was furious.

Then, I was called into the courtroom and Scott grilled me on things that had ZERO to do with the case...he asked about our marriage, the abuse I suffered, whether I thought he loved our kids, whether I thought he loved me, if I'm happy.  It got to the point where the judge finally leaned over and said to me that I was not obligated to answer any of the questions so I just started responding with, "I don't have to answer that."  I was finally let out of the courtroom.  If I had known we had the option to not answer those questions before my son had been brought into the courtroom, I would've said no and left.  But I wasn't told that PRIOR to.

Shortly after that, we met with the kid's Guardian ad Litem and he said that was tantamount to a person ratting out the mafia and then allowing the mafia boss to just "hang out" in the courtroom with him!  🤬 He felt it was judicial misconduct and he'd add it to his report for our custody hearing when it happens.

Then, on March 9th, we were FINALLY scheduled to actually move forward with trial.  The Friday before, Scott had been arrested for driving without a license and failure to get tabs or show proof of insurance (he'd been pulled over about five times since August and claimed sovereign citizenship each time - the right to travel freely and he does not wish to contract with the state, etc) so he had spent the weekend in jail.  Before jury selection began, Scott was given the opportunity to post bail and get out.  He paid his $100 bond and was released.

Jury selection began late Monday morning and took the entire day so testimony was scheduled to begin at 9 a.m. the next morning.  The only witnesses were myself, my son, our CPS worker, and the responding police officer.  Even after the last continuance, Scott didn't have any witnesses.  Tuesday morning, I was called as the first witness and he tried, again, to question me as if I had some sort of vendetta against him and was attempting to take the kids.  The DA asked me if I brought these charges or had anything to do with this and I said no.  At one point, Scott asked me if I was trying to take the kids from him and I said yes, to keep them safe.  He then threatened me with perjury because, apparently in January, I had said no to the same question.  The judge had a sidebar with him and the DA, in chambers.  So, I got to sit there, on the witness stand, bawling, in front of the jury.  It was humiliating.  They came back in and there was nothing left to say so I was released.

We were sequestered so I couldn't hear any other witness testimony and had to sit in the hallway.  They called in my son and my dad, my aunt, and my advocate stayed in the courtroom so he'd have a lot of friendly faces to look at if he needed them.  He didn't remember anything now.  😞  I wasn't sure if it was good thing - we've had him in therapy for over a year due to the PTSD trying to accomplish just that.  But, I suspect he was just telling his dad what Scott maybe suggested Mid say when they were alone.

They called CPS and she presented the reports and photographs.  They then called the police officer and Scott grilled him on his investigative techniques.  For a report that was only a paragraph long, the poor guy was on the stand for an hour.  It was ridiculous.

After all of that, they recalled me.  Scott tried to introduce two pieces of evidence that were never submitted with discovery.  It was a text conversation between us about one of my son's neurology appointments, but only MY texts, not his.  And a doctor's note from over a year prior to the incident that said my son had low/normal hemoglobin and iron, which could have caused him to bruise easily.  Um, he's a little boy.  If that were the case, he'd have bruising everywhere and he did not.  Those two pieces of evidence were ruled inadmissable.  The judge released everyone for the day and instructed the jury to be back at 8:30, but the lawyers and I had to be back at 7:30 in case there was more to be discussed outside of the jury.

Got there Wednesday morning and waited and waited.  Finally, I saw the DA coming down the courthouse hallway and he looked really upset.  We asked him how it was going and be responded, "Terrible."  I immediately asked, "What's wrong?" and he showed me a DVD that he was holding of some CCTV footage in the courtroom from the night before.  He said, "The judge was in the courtroom last night reading the juror notes.  I have to request a mistrial.  We'll have to start over.  I'm so, so sorry."

He went in the courtroom, and I could hear the judge yelling from out in the hallway.  He came back out and I asked what happened.  He said that he just got screamed at and the mistrial motion was denied, we had to proceed.  Then, they were called BACK into the courtroom and I think the defense requested that the charges be dismissed and THAT was granted.  So, since double jeopardy applied, Scott can never be tried again for this offense and we have no grounds for appeal.  The judge, whose misconduct caused what should have been a mistrial, threw out the charges and Scott walked free.  No justice for my son.  No justice for me.  Just done.

I wasted a year of my life to be no better off than I was before.  The kids are still protected by our current order for custody, but that's temporary.  I'm not sure what will happen now when we go back to court for that.  The GAL is going to put all of this in his report for our custody hearing and I know that carries a lot of weight.  I just felt so drained and defeated. 

Afterwards, I found out he had sent his family a text that said, "Praise the Lord, the charges were dismissed."  As if he had won.  It's disgusting.